Punjab Minister Raises Severe Objections Against Central Government
The chief justice selection process for the Punjab and Haryana High Court triggered a major political row between Punjab and the Union Government. Punjab Finance Minister Harpal Singh Cheema publicly slammed the Centre on Sunday.
He strongly objected to appointing Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra as the permanent Chief Justice without consulting the state government. The Union Ministry of Law and Justice issued the official notification clearing the appointment on Saturday.
However, state ministers asserted that the Centre bypassed mandatory legal protocols during the process. Addressing news reporters in Jalandhar, Cheema called the decision a direct assault on the federal structure.
[Aug 6: Collegium Recommends Elevation] ───► [Aug 12: Governor Formal Letter Sent]
│
▼
[Sept 6: State Cabinet Holds Emergency Meet] ◄─── [Sept 5: Union Issues Notification]
Comparative Analysis of Judicial Appointments and Delays
| Judicial Appointment Case | Collegium Recommendation | Administrative Action Status | Procedural Controversy |
| Justice Ashwani Kumar Mishra | Recommended on August 6, 2026 | Notification cleared on September 5, 2026 | Appointed without waiting for Punjab Government’s response |
| Justice GS Sandhawalia | Recommended in July 2024 | Pending over two months before transfer | Union delayed clearance despite senior-most judicial standing |
Finance Minister Cheema highlighted clear procedural flaws in the recent judicial appointment. He noted that the official Memorandum of Procedure requires active consultation with elected state leaders.
Also Read : CM Bhagwant Mann Inaugurates 4th Season Of ‘Khedan Wattan Punjab Diyan-2026’ In Bathinda
Under the established rules, state governments receive a six-week window to submit their specific views. Union Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal and Punjab Governor Gulab Chand Kataria sent formal communications on August 12.
However, the Central Government issued the final notification before Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann could convey state inputs. Consequently, Punjab officials accused the Centre of breaching prescribed constitutional timelines.
Procedural Protocol Timeline for High Court Appointments
| Procedural Phase | Responsible Authority | Mandatory Operational Action |
| Initial Proposal | Supreme Court Collegium | Recommends senior candidate for High Court Chief Justice role |
| State Consultation | Union Law Ministry & Governor | Forwards proposal to elected Chief Minister for formal comments |
| Evaluative Period | State Government | Given up to 6 weeks to submit official state recommendations |
| Executive Notification | President of India / Ministry | Issues final appointment notification upon receiving all inputs |
The controversy over this chief justice selection expands beyond single administrative decisions. Cheema compared this rapid clearance with earlier delays involving senior judges from the same court.
He cited the previous recommendation for Justice GS Sandhawalia to head the Madhya Pradesh High Court. The Supreme Court Collegium submitted that recommendation back in July 2024.
Yet, the Union Government held the file pending for more than two months without clear explanations. Later, the authorities reassigned Justice Sandhawalia to the Himachal Pradesh High Court.
Constitutional Framework and State Financial Context
| Key Governance Parameter | Relevant Legal or Financial Metric | Impact on State Governance |
| Elected Representation | Mandate of 3 crore citizens in Punjab | Bypassing state views undermines democratic representation |
| Constitutional Mandate | Article 217 & Memorandum of Procedure | Enforces joint consultation between Centre and State leaders |
| High Court DA Verdict | ₹14,100 Crore total state financial impact | Court ordered release of pending employee dues within a fortnight |
Cheema asserted that ignoring elected state leaders during the chief justice selection process disrespects three crore Punjabis. The Minister stated that the Constitution creates a balanced federal framework with defined powers.
This legal clash occurs shortly after significant judicial directions against the state treasury. On August 3, a division bench led by Justice Mishra directed Punjab to clear ₹14,100 crore in pending employee dues.
Following the appointment dispute, Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann convened an emergency cabinet meeting to evaluate legal remedies. Official judicial guidelines are available via the Department of Justice Portal.
Ultimately, the controversy surrounding the chief justice selection highlights growing federal friction over administrative boundaries. The Punjab Government vows to defend its constitutional rights against further central interference.